Economy Rent a Car reviews 2026: what renters say about fees and deposits
A 2.0 Trustpilot score sits beside two very different BBB files in the September 2026 records
San Jose, Costa Rica – September 11, 2026 – Economy Rent a Car reviews split almost down the middle, with one group of raters naming a smooth pickup and a cheap rate, and another describing charges added at the counter that they had not planned for. Renters weighing that trade can compare prices on CarRentalMatch for the same dates first.
For this report we read the public economy rent a car reviews on Trustpilot, Yelp and the Better Business Bureau in September 2026, and set them beside what the company states about itself.
What is Economy Rent a Car
Economy Rent a Car is a Costa Rican rental company with its head office in San Jose, listed at Sabana Norte with a Costa Rica telephone line. The national tourism board’s supplier listing describes it as a Costa Rican company with more than 25 years in the business and a fleet in constant renewal. The company profile the brand maintains on Trustpilot puts the network at more than 100 locations in 30 countries, which makes it a home market operator that has expanded through overseas branches and partners.
In the United States the brand trades through Economy Rent-A-Car, Inc., a Florida company recorded by BBB as having started on January 19, 2016, with files at Doral and at Orlando. Yelp lists eight United States locations under the brand.
Locations, files and rental conditions
The two BBB files for the United States arm read very differently, and both are current. The Orlando file carries an A+ letter grade and records the business as BBB accredited since August 22, 2023. The Doral file carries an F letter grade, records the business as not accredited, and shows 16 complaints over three years with 12 of them unanswered. Customer reviews average 1.33 out of 5 from six posts on the Orlando file and 1 out of 5 from six posts at Doral.
The insurance line matters most in the home market. Costa Rican law requires third party liability cover on every rental in the country, and it cannot be declined or replaced by a credit card benefit, so a rate quoted online is not the amount that leaves the counter. Renters comparing that market are looking at rate plus mandatory cover rather than the headline figure alone.
What economy rent a car reviews say about fees and deposits
Trustpilot scored the brand at 2.0 out of 5 from 844 reviews when we read it on September 11, 2026, with almost half of raters at five stars and almost as many at one. The profile has been claimed since December 2016, and Trustpilot records that the company has replied to 3 percent of its negative reviews. Yelp shows a 1.4 average from 1,364 reviews across the brand.
The praise is consistent about people. Positive reviewers name patient counter staff, a shuttle that arrived, and deposits returned without a chase. The critical posts cluster on money: renters report insurance charges they say were added at pickup, card processing fees, toll charges, and credit card holds in the range of 1,000 to 3,000 dollars. On BBB, renters report disputes over retained deposits, cleaning fees on cars they describe as already marked, and confusion about whether the rental was supplied by Economy or by a partner agency. BBB states that “Customer Reviews are not used in the calculation of the BBB Letter Grade Rating,” so the letter grades on those files reflect complaint handling rather than the star averages.
How to get the best price
Pricing the same dates and pickup point across several suppliers, then reading the total after taxes, mandatory cover and fees rather than the daily rate, is what shows where this brand actually lands. A free tool such as CarRentalMatch checks offers across suppliers for one trip.
Two habits cover the rest. A credit card in the renter’s own name with room for the hold avoids a refusal at the desk, and photographs of the car at pickup and at return, kept until the final charge clears, give a record if a charge is queried.
Verdict on economy rent a car reviews in 2026
Read together, economy rent a car reviews describe a low headline rate that is decided at the counter rather than at booking. Raters who arrived knowing what the mandatory cover costs and what hold to expect account for most of the five star posts. Pricing the same trip against two or three other suppliers is worth the minute it takes.
About CarRentalMatch
CarRentalMatch is a free car rental price comparison website. It shows rates from a range of suppliers for the same pickup point and dates, so travellers can see the spread. It does not rent vehicles itself. CarRentalMatch does not own, operate or represent any rental brand named in this release.
Media Contact
Company Name: CarRentalMatch
Contact Person: Media Relations
Email: Send Email
Country: United States
Website: https://carrentalmatch.com/
